Skip to main content
Lemma

TMUA practice: Necessary Sufficient, problem 5

A TMUA-calibre necessary sufficient problem at difficulty 4 of 5, with the full worked solution.

The question
The quadratic f(x)=x2−2px+qf(x) = x^2 - 2px + q has two distinct real roots, and the difference between the roots is greater than 22 and less than 44 — call this statement (∗)(\ast). Which one of the following is the **necessary and sufficient** condition for (∗)(\ast)?
A q<p2<q+3q < p^2 < q + 3
B q+1<p2<q+4 and p>0q + 1 < p^2 < q + 4\ \text{and}\ p > 0
C q+1≤p2≤q+4q + 1 \le p^2 \le q + 4
D q<p2−1<q+3q < p^2 - 1 < q + 3
E q<p2−1 and p2<q+4q < p^2 - 1\ \text{and}\ p^2 < q + 4

The correct answer is highlighted. D

Worked solution

Roots: p±p2−qp \pm \sqrt{p^2 - q}. Difference: 2p2−q2\sqrt{p^2 - q}.

Real and distinct: p2−q>0p^2 - q > 0. Difference between 2 and 4: 1<p2−q<21 < \sqrt{p^2 - q} < 2, i.e. 1<p2−q<41 < p^2 - q < 4, i.e. q+1<p2<q+4q + 1 < p^2 < q + 4, i.e. q<p2−1q < p^2 - 1 AND p2−1<q+3p^2 - 1 < q + 3.

So q<p2−1<q+3q < p^2 - 1 < q + 3. Answer: D.