Skip to main content
Lemma
Inequalities Difficulty 4

TMUA practice: Inequalities, problem 3

A TMUA-calibre inequalities problem at difficulty 4 of 5, with the full worked solution.

The question
Consider the statement: x(α−x)<y(α−y)x(\alpha - x) < y(\alpha - y) for all x,yx, y with 0<x<y<10 < x < y < 1. The statement is true
A iff α≥2\text{iff } \alpha \ge 2
B iff α>2\text{iff } \alpha > 2
C iff α<−1\text{iff } \alpha < -1
D for no value of α\text{for no value of } \alpha

The correct answer is highlighted. A

Worked solution

Let f(t)=t(α−t)=αt−t2f(t) = t(\alpha - t) = \alpha t - t^2. The statement says f(x)<f(y)f(x) < f(y) whenever 0<x<y<10 < x < y < 1 — that is, ff is strictly increasing on (0,1)(0, 1).

f′(t)=α−2t.f'(t) = \alpha - 2t.

ff is increasing on (0,1)(0,1) exactly when f′(t)≥0f'(t) \ge 0 throughout, and since tt ranges up to (but not including) 11, this needs

α≥2t  for all t∈(0,1)  ⟺  α≥2.\alpha \ge 2t \ \text{ for all } t \in (0,1) \iff \alpha \ge 2.

  • If α≥2\alpha \ge 2: f′(t)=α−2t≥2−2t>0f'(t) = \alpha - 2t \ge 2 - 2t > 0 on (0,1)(0,1), so ff is strictly increasing and the statement holds.
  • If α<2\alpha < 2: pick tt close to 11; then f′(t)=α−2t<0f'(t) = \alpha - 2t < 0, so ff decreases somewhere in (0,1)(0,1) and the statement fails.

Hence the statement is true if and only if α≥2\alpha \ge 2.

Answer: A.