Skip to main content
Lemma
TMUA Paper 2

TMUA Mathematical Reasoning (Paper 2)

Necessary and sufficient, proof by contradiction, quantifier negation, and the moves Paper 2 is built around.

Paper 2 is Mathematical Reasoning. The mathematics in it is not new; the test is whether you can read a mathematical claim precisely, name its converse, find a counter-example, identify the precise step at which a proof breaks, and translate quantifier statements between symbols and prose. Candidates who do well on Paper 2 have drilled five specific moves until they are automatic under time pressure.

  • Necessary versus sufficient. AA is sufficient for BB if ABA \Rightarrow B. AA is necessary for BB if BAB \Rightarrow A. Confused half the time under time pressure unless drilled deliberately.
  • Counter-example construction. For a false universal claim, the whole question reduces to producing one xx that breaks it. The candidate who can summon counter-examples for the standard families (small integers, zero, edge cases, negative values) saves minutes.
  • Spotting the broken step in a proof. Almost always one of: division by something that could be zero; taking a square root and dropping the negative case; multiplying both sides of an inequality by an expression whose sign is unknown; asserting “for all” when only “for some” has been shown.
  • Quantifier negation. The negation of “for all xx, P(x)P(x)” is “there exists xx such that not P(x)P(x)”. Two questions per Paper 2, free marks once drilled.
  • Translating prose to logic. “No AA is BB unless CC”, “every AA that is BB must be CC” appear several times per Paper 2 and need reliable reformulation as x(P(x)Q(x))\forall x (P(x) \to Q(x)) form.

The move. Paper 2 questions look varied but rely on a small, fixed vocabulary of logical constructions. Learn the vocabulary, name the construction the question is using, then the answer follows.

Worked problems on this topic

5 pages

Free to read. Each carries the full worked solution; a video walkthrough where one has been produced.