Skip to main content
Lemma

TMUA practice: Trig Equations, problem 3

A TMUA-calibre trig equations problem at difficulty 4 of 5, with the full worked solution.

The question
Suppose aa is a real number such that the equation a⋅(sin⁡x+sin⁡(2x))=sin⁡(3x)a\cdot(\sin{x}+\sin{(2x)}) = \sin{(3x)} has more than one solution in the interval (0,π)(0, \pi) . The set of all such aa that can be written in the form (p,q)∪(q,r),(p,q) \cup (q,r), where p,q,p, q, and rr are real numbers with p<q<rp < q< r . What is p+q+rp+q+r ?
A −4{-}4
B −1{-}1
C 00
D 11
E 44

The correct answer is highlighted. A

Worked solution

We are given that a⋅(sin⁡x+sin⁡(2x))=sin⁡(3x)a\cdot(\sin{x}+\sin{(2x)})=\sin{(3x)}

Using the sine double angle formula combine with the fact that sin⁡(3x)=sin⁡x⋅(4cos⁡2x−1)\sin{(3x)} = \sin{x}\cdot(4\cos^2{x}-1) , which can be derived using sine angle addition with sin⁡(2x+x)\sin{(2x + x)} , we have

a⋅(sin⁡x+2sin⁡xcos⁡x)=sin⁡x⋅(4cos⁡2x−1)a\cdot(\sin{x}+2\sin{x}\cos{x})=\sin{x}\cdot(4\cos^2{x}-1)

Since sin⁡x≠0\sin{x} \ne 0 as it is on the open interval (0,π)(0, \pi) , we can divide out sin⁡x\sin{x} from both sides, leaving us with

a⋅(1+2cos⁡x)=4cos⁡2x−1a\cdot(1+2\cos{x})=4\cos^2{x}-1

Now, distributing aa and rearranging, we achieve the equation

4cos⁡2x−2acos⁡x−(1+a)=04\cos^2{x} - 2a\cos{x} - (1+a) = 0

which is a quadratic in cos⁡x\cos{x} .

Applying the quadratic formula to solve for cos⁡x\cos{x} , we get

cos⁡x=2a±4a2+4(4)(1+a)8\cos{x} =\frac{2a\pm\sqrt{4a^2+4(4)(1+a)}}{8}

and expanding the terms under the radical, we get

cos⁡x=2a±4a2+16a+168\cos{x} =\frac{2a\pm\sqrt{4a^2+16a+16}}{8}

Factoring, since 4a2+16a+16=(2a+4)24a^2+16a+16 = (2a+4)^2 , we can simplify our expression even further to

cos⁡x=a±(a+2)4\cos{x} =\frac{a\pm(a+2)}{4}

Now, solving for our two solutions, cos⁡x=−12\cos{x} = -\frac{1}{2} and cos⁡x=a+12\cos{x} = \frac{a+1}{2} .

Since cos⁡x=−12\cos{x} = -\frac{1}{2} yields a solution that is valid for all aa , that being x=2π3x = \frac{2\pi}{3} , we must now solve for the case where a+12\frac{a+1}{2} yields a valid value.

As x∈(0,π)x\in (0, \pi) , cos⁡x∈(−1,1)\cos{x}\in (-1, 1) , and therefore a+12∈(−1,1)\frac{a+1}{2}\in (-1, 1) , and a∈(−3,1)a\in(-3,1) .

There is one more case we must consider inside this interval though, the case where a+12=−12\frac{a+1}{2} = -\frac{1}{2} , as this would lead to a double root for cos⁡x\cos{x} , yielding only one valid solution for xx . Solving for this case, a≠−2a \ne -2 .

Therefore, combining this fact with our solution interval, a∈(−3,−2)∪(−2,1)a\in(-3, -2) \cup (-2, 1) , so the answer is −3−2+1=(A) −4-3-2+1 = \boxed{\textbf{(A) } {-}4} .

  • DavidHovey