Skip to main content
Lemma

TMUA practice: Arithmetic Series, problem 4

A TMUA-calibre arithmetic series problem at difficulty 4 of 5, with the full worked solution.

The question
Three non-zero real numbers form an arithmetic progression (in that order); their squares, taken in the same order, form a geometric progression. What are all possible values of the common ratio of that geometric progression?
A 11
B 2 and 122 \text{ and } \tfrac{1}{2}
C 2\sqrt{2}
D 3+22 and 3−223 + 2\sqrt{2} \text{ and } 3 - 2\sqrt{2}
E no such progression exists\text{no such progression exists}

The correct answer is highlighted. D

Worked solution

Write the three terms of the AP in symmetric form:   a−d, a, a+d  \;a - d,\, a,\, a + d\; with a≠0a \ne 0. (Symmetric choice simplifies the algebra.)

Their squares are   (a−d)2, a2, (a+d)2\;(a - d)^{2},\, a^{2},\, (a + d)^{2}.

For these to be three consecutive terms of a GP, the middle term squared equals the product of the outers:

(a2)2  =  (a−d)2 (a+d)2  =  ((a−d)(a+d))2  =  (a2−d2)2.\left(a^{2}\right)^{2} \;=\; (a - d)^{2}\,(a + d)^{2} \;=\; \bigl((a - d)(a + d)\bigr)^{2} \;=\; \bigl(a^{2} - d^{2}\bigr)^{2}.

So   a4=(a2−d2)2\;a^{4} = (a^{2} - d^{2})^{2}, which gives   a2=±(a2−d2)\;a^{2} = \pm (a^{2} - d^{2}).

  • Case 1: a2=a2−d2a^{2} = a^{2} - d^{2} gives d2=0d^{2} = 0, hence d=0d = 0. The AP is constant, all three numbers equal aa. Their squares are all a2a^{2}, a GP of common ratio 11. But Dorofeev’s problem requires three distinct terms (otherwise the AP/GP framing is degenerate); also, the common ratio 11 is the trivial case that occurs for any constant sequence and is usually excluded.

  • Case 2: a2=−(a2−d2)a^{2} = -(a^{2} - d^{2}) gives 2a2=d22 a^{2} = d^{2}, hence d=±a2d = \pm a\sqrt{2}.

Compute the common ratio r=a2/(a−d)2r = a^{2}/(a - d)^{2} in each sub-case.

Sub-case d=a2d = a\sqrt{2}:   a−d=a(1−2)\;a - d = a(1 - \sqrt{2}), so (a−d)2=a2(1−2)2=a2(3−22)(a - d)^{2} = a^{2}(1 - \sqrt{2})^{2} = a^{2}(3 - 2\sqrt{2}). Therefore

r  =  a2a2(3−22)  =  13−22  =  3+22(3)2−(22)2  =  3+229−8  =  3+22.r \;=\; \frac{a^{2}}{a^{2}(3 - 2\sqrt{2})} \;=\; \frac{1}{3 - 2\sqrt{2}} \;=\; \frac{3 + 2\sqrt{2}}{(3)^{2} - (2\sqrt{2})^{2}} \;=\; \frac{3 + 2\sqrt{2}}{9 - 8} \;=\; 3 + 2\sqrt{2}.

Sub-case d=−a2d = -a\sqrt{2}: by the same calculation with 1−21 - \sqrt{2} replaced by 1+21 + \sqrt{2},

r  =  1(1+2)2  =  13+22  =  3−22.r \;=\; \frac{1}{(1 + \sqrt{2})^{2}} \;=\; \frac{1}{3 + 2\sqrt{2}} \;=\; 3 - 2\sqrt{2}.

Both values are positive (since 3>22≈2.833 > 2\sqrt{2} \approx 2.83), so they are valid GP common ratios. The two possible common ratios are   r=3+22  \;r = 3 + 2\sqrt{2}\; and   r=3−22\;r = 3 - 2\sqrt{2}. This is option D.

(Sanity check:   (3+22)(3−22)=9−8=1\;(3 + 2\sqrt{2})(3 - 2\sqrt{2}) = 9 - 8 = 1, so the two ratios are reciprocals — consistent with the symmetry d→−dd \to -d that reverses the order of the AP, which reverses the GP and inverts its common ratio.)

Why the other options fail.

  • A, 11: only the degenerate constant case, usually excluded.
  • B, 22 and 12\tfrac{1}{2}: the right idea (the ratios are reciprocals) but the wrong numbers.
  • C, 2\sqrt{2}: arises from d=a2d = a\sqrt{2} if a student computes ∣d∣/∣a∣|d|/|a| instead of the GP ratio.
  • E: a valid non-degenerate progression exists, e.g. 1, 1+2, 1+221,\, 1 + \sqrt{2},\, 1 + 2\sqrt{2} in AP whose squares are 1, 3+22, 9+42+8=17+1221,\, 3 + 2\sqrt{2},\, 9 + 4\sqrt{2} + 8 = 17 + 12\sqrt{2}, and indeed (3+22)2=9+122+8=17+122(3 + 2\sqrt{2})^{2} = 9 + 12\sqrt{2} + 8 = 17 + 12\sqrt{2} ✓.

The lesson: the symmetric form a−d, a, a+da - d,\, a,\, a + d for three terms of an AP makes the algebra cleaner. The condition ‘middle squared = product of outers’ characterises GP triples. The two valid common ratios are reciprocals.