Skip to main content
Lemma

TMUA practice: Graph Transformations, problem 3

A TMUA-calibre graph transformations problem at difficulty 4 of 5, with the full worked solution.

The question
Let   f(x)=(x+1)(x2)(x5)  \;f(x) = (x + 1)(x - 2)(x - 5)\; and   g(x)=(x+4)(x+1)(x2)  \;g(x) = (x + 4)(x + 1)(x - 2)\; for all real xx. Which one of the following statements about gg in relation to ff is true?
A g(x)=f(x3),  i.e. the graph of g is the graph of f translated 3 units to the rightg(x) = f(x - 3),\; \text{i.e. the graph of } g \text{ is the graph of } f \text{ translated } 3 \text{ units to the right}
B g(x)=f(x),  i.e. the graph of g is the reflection of the graph of f in the y-axisg(x) = f(-x),\; \text{i.e. the graph of } g \text{ is the reflection of the graph of } f \text{ in the } y\text{-axis}
C g(x)=f(x+3),  i.e. the graph of g is the graph of f translated 3 units to the leftg(x) = f(x + 3),\; \text{i.e. the graph of } g \text{ is the graph of } f \text{ translated } 3 \text{ units to the left}
D g(x)=f(x)+3,  i.e. the graph of g is the graph of f translated 3 units upwardg(x) = f(x) + 3,\; \text{i.e. the graph of } g \text{ is the graph of } f \text{ translated } 3 \text{ units upward}
E g(x)=f(x),  i.e. the graph of g is the reflection of the graph of f in the x-axisg(x) = -f(x),\; \text{i.e. the graph of } g \text{ is the reflection of the graph of } f \text{ in the } x\text{-axis}

The correct answer is highlighted. C

Worked solution

Compare the two factorisations.

  •   f(x)=(x+1)(x2)(x5)  \;f(x) = (x + 1)(x - 2)(x - 5)\; has zeros at x=1,2,5x = -1,\, 2,\, 5.
  •   g(x)=(x+4)(x+1)(x2)  \;g(x) = (x + 4)(x + 1)(x - 2)\; has zeros at x=4,1,2x = -4,\, -1,\, 2.

Each zero of gg is exactly 33 less than the corresponding zero of ff:

14,21,52(each subtracts 3).-1 \to -4, \quad 2 \to -1, \quad 5 \to 2 \quad (\text{each subtracts } 3).

This is consistent with a translation 33 units to the left, which corresponds to replacing xx by x+3x + 3 in ff.

Verify by substitution:

f(x+3)  =  ((x+3)+1)((x+3)2)((x+3)5)  =  (x+4)(x+1)(x2)  =  g(x).f(x + 3) \;=\; ((x + 3) + 1)\bigl((x + 3) - 2\bigr)\bigl((x + 3) - 5\bigr) \;=\; (x + 4)(x + 1)(x - 2) \;=\; g(x).

The identity holds for every xx, so g(x)=f(x+3)g(x) = f(x + 3), and the graph of gg is the graph of ff translated 33 units to the left. This is option C.

Why the other options fail.

  • A has the direction wrong. f(x3)f(x - 3) shifts right by 33, sending the zeros to 1+3=2-1 + 3 = 2,   2+3=5\; 2 + 3 = 5,   5+3=8\; 5 + 3 = 8, which would give roots {2,5,8}\{2,\, 5,\, 8\}, not {4,1,2}\{-4,\, -1,\, 2\}.
  • B, reflection in yy-axis, would send the zeros to {1,2,5}\{1,\, -2,\, -5\}, again not the zeros of gg.
  • D, f(x)+3f(x) + 3, does not change the xx-coordinates of the zeros; for instance f(1)+3=0+3=30f(-1) + 3 = 0 + 3 = 3 \neq 0, so 1-1 is not a zero of f(x)+3f(x) + 3. But 1-1 is a zero of gg.
  • E, f(x)-f(x), has the same zeros as ff, namely {1,2,5}\{-1,\, 2,\, 5\}, not {4,1,2}\{-4,\, -1,\, 2\}.

The lesson: a horizontal translation by hh shifts every zero by hh (and preserves multiplicities). Comparing two sets of zeros that all differ by the same constant is a clean tell for a horizontal translation.